When it comes to finding the best supermarket in New Jersey, opinions can vary widely. However, one way to gauge public sentiment is through customer reviews on platforms like Google. Based on extensive analysis of customer feedback, here are the highest-rated supermarkets in each of New Jersey’s 21 counties. To qualify for consideration, each supermarket had to have amassed a significant number of reviews, typically exceeding one thousand, ensuring a broad and representative sample of customer opinions.
- Bagliani’s Market – Hammonton: 4.8 stars (1,900+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Absecon: 4.2 stars (1,600+ reviews)
- ShopRite of English Creek: 4.2 stars (1,900+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Galloway: 4.2 stars (1,600+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Hammonton: 4.2 stars (1,100+ reviews)
- Trader Joe’s of Westwood: 4.7 stars (1,600+ reviews)
- Trader Joe’s Paramus: 4.6 stars (3,800+ reviews)
- Trader Joe’s of Edgewater: 4.6 stars (3,300+ reviews)
- Stew Leonard’s Farm Fresh Food & Wine: 4.6 starts (2,300+ reviews)
- Maywood’s Marketplace: 4.6 stars (1,300+ reviews)
- Trader Joe’s of Marlton: 4.7 stars (1,600+ reviews)
- Wegmans of Mount Laurel: 4.6 stars (3,100+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Burlington: 4.3 stars (3,100+ reviews)
- ShopRite or Hainesport: 4.3 stars (1,600+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Delran: 4.1 stars (1,600+ reviews)
- Wegmans of Cherry Hill: 4.6 stars (3,700+ reviews)
- Sprouts Farmers Market: 4.5 stars (696 reviews)
- Aldi of Stratford: 4.5 stars (1,200+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Berlin: 4.3 stars (1,700+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Chews Landing: 4.3 stars (1,500+ reviews)
- Whole Foods of Cherry Hill: 4.3 stars (1,400+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Marmora: 4.4 stars (1,300+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Rio Grande: 4.3 stars (2,000+ reviews)
- Acme of Wildwood: 4.1 stars (1,500+ reviews)
- Acme of Cape May Courthouse: 4.1 stars (1,200+ reviews)
- Acme of North Cape May: 4.1 stars (730+ reviews)
- Elmer IGA: 4.2 stars (380+ reviews)
- Acme of Pennsville: 4.1 stars (860+ reviews)
- Acme of Woodstown: 4.0 stars (830+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Essex Green: 4.3 stars (2,700+ reviews)
- Aldi of Bloomfield: 4.3 stars (2,600+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Brookdale: 4.3 stars (2,500+ reviews)
- Whole Foods of West Orange: 4.3 stars (1,800+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Livingston: 4.3 stars (1,800+ reviews)
- Verchio’s Produce Outlet – Sewell: 4.5 stars (4,500+ reviews)
- ShopRite of West Deptford: 4.3 stars (1,300+ reviews)
- Aldi of Woodbury: 4.3 stars (1,200+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Sewell: 4.3 stars (1,000+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Glassboro: 4.2 stars (2,400+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Hoboken: 4.3 stars (2,800+ reviews)
- Acme of Stadium Plaza: 4.2 stars (1,400+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Metro Plaza: 4.1 stars (5,100+ reviews)
- Extra Supermarket of Jersey City: 4.1 stars (1,900+ reviews)
- Acme of Newport Plaza: 4.1 stars (900+ reviews)
- Costco of Flemington: 4.6 stars (2,300+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Flemington: 4.4 stars (1,300+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Clinton: 4.2 stars (1,100+ reviews)
- Walmart Supercenter of Flemington: 4.0 stars (2,300+ reviews)
- Trader Joe’s of Princeton: 4.7 stars (3,300+ reviews)
- Wegmans of Princeton: 4.6 stars (2,400+ reviews)
- Whole Foods: 4.4 stars (1,400+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Hamilton Square: 4.3 stars (2,200+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Lawrenceville: 4.3 stars (1,300+ reviews)
- Wegmans of Woodbridge: 4.8 stars (1,800+ reviews)
- Trader Joe’s of North Brunswick: 4.6 stars (1,900+ reviews)
- Whole Foods of Metuchen: 4.4 stars (1,800+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Woodbridge: 4.3 stars (3,200+ reviews)
- ShopRite of North Brunswick: 4.3 stars (2,400+ reviews)
- Wegmans of Ocean Township: 4.6 stars (2,600+ reviews)
- Trader Joe’s of Shrewsbury: 4.6 stars (1,700+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Shrewsbury: 4.5 stars (1,300+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Howell: 4.4 stars (1,500+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Wall: 4.4 stars (1,200+ reviews)
- Trader Joe’s of Denville: 4.7 stars (1,100+ reviews)
- Wegmans of Parsippany-Troy Hills: 4.6 stars (4,100+ reviews)
- Trader Joe’s of Florham Park: 4.6 stars (1,400+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Greater Morristown: 4.4 stars (3,000+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Rockaway: 4.4 stars (1,800+ reviews)
- Trader Joe’s of Brick: 4.6 stars (1,400+ reviews)
- Seasons Lakewood — Kosher Supermarket: 4.6 stars (1,000+ reviews)
- Aldi of Toms River: 4.3 stars (1,600+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Route 37: 4.2 stars (3,500+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Fischer Bay: 4.2 stars (1,700+ reviews)
- Trader Joe’s of Wayne: 4.6 stars (1,800+ reviews)
- C Town of Passaic: 4.3 stars (800+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Passaic on Paulison Ave: 4.2 stars (3,100+ reviews)
- Super Fresh: 4.2 stars (1,100+ reviews)
- Elmer IGA: 4.2 stars (380+ reviews)
- Acme of Pennsville: 4.1 stars (860+ reviews)
- Acme of Woodstown: 4.0 stars (830+ reviews)
- Trader Joe’s of Bridgewater: 4.7 stars (1,100+ reviews)
- Wegmans of Bridgewater: 4.6 stars (2,700+ reviews)
- Whole Foods of Bridgewater: 4.4 stars (1,200+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Bound Brook: 4.3 stars (2,300+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Somerville: 4.3 stars (2,200+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Sparta: 4.5 stars (4,500+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Byram: 4.4 stars (1,800+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Montague: 4.2 stars (1,800+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Newton: 4.1 stars (1,700+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Franklin: 4.0 stars (1,300+ reviews)
- Trader Joe’s Westfield: 4.7 stars (3000+ reviews)
- Aldi of Union: 4.4 stars (1,600+ reviews)
- Lidl of Union: 4.4 stars (1,500+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Linden: 4.3 stars (3,300+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Union (Route 22): 4.3 stars (2,900+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Greenwich: 4.4 stars (2,100+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Washington: 4.2 stars (500+ reviews)
- Stop & Shop of Phillipsburg: 4.2 stars (600+ reviews)
- Weiss of Hackettstown: 4.2 stars (500+ reviews)
- ShopRite of Mansfield: 4.1 stars (1,300+ reviews)
Atlantic County
ShopRite of Somers Point
Located in Somers Point, ShopRite stands out in Atlantic County for its exceptional service and wide selection of products. Customers consistently praise its cleanliness, friendly staff, and competitive pricing.
Bergen County
Wegmans Food Markets
Wegmans, with locations in Montvale and Paramus, earns top marks in Bergen County. Known for its upscale atmosphere, vast organic selections, and culinary expertise, Wegmans is a favorite for many residents.
Burlington County
ShopRite of Marlton
In Marlton, Burlington County, ShopRite is highly rated for its fresh produce, well-organized aisles, and community involvement. Customers appreciate its convenient location and overall shopping experience.
Camden County
Trader Joe’s
Trader Joe’s, located in Cherry Hill, Camden County, receives accolades for its unique products, attentive customer service, and pleasant shopping atmosphere. It’s a preferred choice for shoppers looking for specialty items.
Cape May County
Acme Markets
Acme Markets in Cape May Court House is celebrated for its friendly service, quality meat and seafood offerings, and comprehensive selection of grocery items. It consistently earns high marks from local customers.
Cumberland County
ShopRite of Millville
ShopRite in Millville stands out in Cumberland County for its affordable prices, diverse product range, and commitment to customer satisfaction. It’s noted for its cleanliness and efficient checkout process.
Essex County
Whole Foods Market
Whole Foods Market in West Orange is Essex County’s top-rated supermarket, known for its organic and gourmet offerings, sustainable practices, and dedication to high-quality products. It’s a favorite among health-conscious shoppers.
Gloucester County
ShopRite of Glassboro
ShopRite in Glassboro, Gloucester County, is praised for its friendly staff, expansive produce section, and frequent sales and promotions. It’s regarded as a cornerstone of the local community.
Hudson County
Trader Joe’s
Trader Joe’s in Hoboken receives top honors in Hudson County for its unique product lineup, excellent customer service, and convenient location. It’s a popular destination for urban shoppers.
Hunterdon County
ShopRite of Hunterdon County
ShopRite in Flemington is the top-rated choice in Hunterdon County, known for its cleanliness, wide array of international foods, and commitment to customer satisfaction. It’s a preferred shopping destination for many residents.
Mercer County
Wegmans Food Markets
Wegmans in Princeton earns the highest ratings in Mercer County for its upscale environment, extensive product selection, and dedication to customer service. It’s considered a standout in the region.
Middlesex County
ShopRite of East Brunswick
ShopRite in East Brunswick is Middlesex County’s highest-rated supermarket, noted for its fresh produce, competitive prices, and efficient checkout process. It’s highly regarded by local shoppers.
Monmouth County
Trader Joe’s
Trader Joe’s in Shrewsbury is Monmouth County’s top-rated supermarket, known for its unique products, attentive service, and pleasant shopping experience. It’s a favorite among residents seeking quality and variety.
Morris County
ShopRite of Greater Morristown
ShopRite in Morris Plains stands out in Morris County for its expansive selection, cleanliness, and community involvement. It consistently receives high praise from customers for its overall shopping experience.
Ocean County
ShopRite of Manchester
ShopRite in Manchester Township is highly rated in Ocean County for its friendly staff, comprehensive product offerings, and commitment to customer satisfaction. It’s a preferred choice for many local shoppers.
Passaic County
Trader Joe’s
Trader Joe’s in Wayne earns top marks in Passaic County for its unique products, excellent customer service, and convenient location. It’s a beloved shopping destination among county residents.
Salem County
ShopRite of Salem County
ShopRite in Pennsville is Salem County’s highest-rated supermarket, known for its friendly atmosphere, quality products, and competitive prices. It’s a staple in the community for its reliability and service.
Somerset County
ShopRite of Somerset
ShopRite in Somerset is Somerset County’s top-rated choice, celebrated for its cleanliness, diverse product selection, and attentive staff. It consistently delivers a superior shopping experience.
Sussex County
ShopRite of Sussex County
ShopRite in Newton is the highest-rated supermarket in Sussex County, noted for its affordability, fresh produce, and commitment to customer satisfaction. It’s a preferred destination for local shoppers.
Union County
Whole Foods Market
Whole Foods Market in Clark is Union County’s top-rated supermarket, known for its organic offerings, sustainability initiatives, and high-quality products. It’s favored by health-conscious shoppers in the area.
Warren County
ShopRite of Washington
ShopRite in Washington Township is Warren County’s highest-rated supermarket, recognized for its friendly service, extensive grocery selection, and community involvement. It’s a trusted name among local residents.
These top-rated supermarkets across New Jersey’s 21 counties exemplify excellence in customer service, product quality, and community engagement. Whether you’re seeking organic produce, specialty items, or everyday essentials, these supermarkets have earned the trust and admiration of their customers through consistent delivery of exceptional shopping experiences. For residents and visitors alike, these supermarkets represent the pinnacle of grocery shopping in the Garden State.
