In a landmark decision that has significant implications for workers across New Jersey, the New Jersey Supreme Court recently ruled in the case of Musker v. Suuchi, Inc., establishing that commissions are to be considered wages under the state’s Wage Payment Law (WPL). This ruling, handed down on March 17, 2025, clarifies a critical issue regarding workers’ rights and extends protections for employees who rely on commissions as a substantial portion of their income.
For businesses and workers alike, the decision brings important changes to how commissions are treated, especially in terms of timely payment and enforcement of payment obligations. The case centers around the experiences of Rosalyn Musker, a sales employee at Suuchi, Inc., a company specializing in software sales. Musker’s claim not only challenged the way commissions were paid but also called into question whether those commissions should be subject to the same legal protections as regular wages under the WPL.
Background: The Musker v. Suuchi, Inc. Case
The case revolves around Rosalyn Musker, who worked in a sales role at Suuchi, Inc., a technology company that provides software solutions to businesses. Musker was part of the sales team that earned commissions based on the software deals they closed. However, Musker’s complaint arose when she claimed that Suuchi did not pay her earned commissions in a timely manner, nor did they adhere to the agreed-upon terms for commission payments.
At the heart of Musker’s lawsuit was a critical question: Are commissions considered a form of wages under New Jersey’s Wage Payment Law? In New Jersey, the Wage Payment Law (WPL) ensures that employees are paid their wages on time, and that they are compensated fairly for their work. However, prior to this ruling, there had been some ambiguity about whether commissions, often tied to sales performance and paid separately from base salaries, were classified as wages.
The Court’s Decision: Commissions Are Wages
In its ruling, the New Jersey Supreme Court decisively concluded that commissions do indeed fall under the definition of wages as per the state’s Wage Payment Law. This landmark decision fundamentally expands the scope of the WPL, ensuring that employees who earn commissions are entitled to the same protections that apply to regular wages.
The court held that because commissions are compensation for services rendered, they are subject to the same wage payment requirements—meaning they must be paid in accordance with the schedule set forth in employment contracts or as agreed upon between the employer and employee. Under this ruling, if an employer fails to pay earned commissions on time, they may be in violation of the WPL, which could lead to penalties and other legal consequences.
Why This Ruling Matters
This ruling has far-reaching consequences for both employers and employees throughout New Jersey. Here’s why this decision is so important:
1. Expanded Protections for Workers
Workers who rely on commissions as a significant portion of their earnings now have stronger legal protections under the Wage Payment Law. The court’s decision clarifies that employers must treat commissions the same way they treat hourly wages, salary payments, or bonuses when it comes to paying employees on time. For salespeople, real estate agents, and other commission-based workers, this ruling ensures that the commissions they earn cannot be withheld or delayed without legal consequences.
2. Clarity for Employers
Prior to this ruling, some employers may have been unclear about the status of commissions under the WPL, potentially leading to inconsistent practices regarding when and how commissions were paid. With the court’s ruling, employers are now on notice that commissions are considered wages, and as such, must comply with the law’s strict payment schedule provisions. This clarity will help businesses avoid costly legal disputes and penalties by ensuring they meet their obligations to pay employees promptly.
3. Legal Recourse for Employees
For employees who have experienced delayed or unpaid commissions, the ruling provides an important avenue for legal recourse. Employees can now seek compensation through the New Jersey Department of Labor and Workforce Development or through civil lawsuits if employers fail to pay earned commissions on time. This adds an additional layer of protection for workers, particularly in industries like sales, where commission-based pay structures are common.
4. Promoting Fairness and Accountability
The decision also highlights the importance of fairness in employment contracts and the need for businesses to be transparent about compensation policies. As the court emphasized, commissions are an integral part of many workers’ livelihoods, and withholding or delaying these payments creates financial hardship for employees who depend on them.
The Legal Implications of Musker v. Suuchi, Inc.
The decision in Musker v. Suuchi, Inc. comes at a time when workers’ rights and fair pay have become prominent issues in New Jersey and across the nation. The ruling reaffirms that the Wage Payment Law is designed to ensure that employees are paid for the work they perform, regardless of the structure of their compensation. By including commissions in the definition of wages, the court also reinforces the idea that compensation for work—whether hourly, salaried, or commission-based—is a right that cannot be delayed or withheld by employers.
For employers, this means a closer look at their commission payment policies, and potentially revising them to ensure compliance with state law. Any contractual agreements regarding commissions—whether tied to sales goals, performance metrics, or other benchmarks—must be clear and align with the payment requirements under the Wage Payment Law.
Key Takeaways from the Musker v. Suuchi Decision
- Commissions are Wages: Commissions are now considered wages under New Jersey law and must be paid in accordance with the state’s Wage Payment Law.
- Timely Payment is Required: Employers must ensure that earned commissions are paid in a timely manner as agreed upon in employment contracts.
- Employees Have Legal Recourse: If employers fail to pay commissions, employees now have the ability to take legal action and seek compensation through the New Jersey Department of Labor or via lawsuits.
- Businesses Must Comply: Employers in New Jersey should review their commission policies to ensure compliance with the Wage Payment Law and avoid potential legal consequences.
Implications for the Future
This ruling sets a significant precedent for future cases involving commission-based compensation. By explicitly recognizing commissions as wages, the New Jersey Supreme Court has paved the way for further protections for workers in commission-driven industries. It also signals a shift toward a more inclusive interpretation of labor laws that prioritize fairness and equitable treatment for all workers, regardless of how their compensation is structured.
Employers will need to adjust their payroll systems, sales contracts, and compensation policies to avoid the risk of non-compliance with the WPL. Additionally, employees who rely on commissions will now be better equipped to advocate for their rights and seek legal remedies in the event of disputes over unpaid or delayed commissions.
Conclusion: A Win for Workers’ Rights in New Jersey
The Musker v. Suuchi, Inc. decision is a major victory for workers’ rights in New Jersey, especially those in industries where commissions make up a significant portion of their income. By clarifying that commissions are to be treated as wages under the Wage Payment Law, the New Jersey Supreme Court has provided stronger protections for workers, ensuring they are paid fairly and on time for their work.
For both workers and employers in New Jersey, this ruling is a reminder of the importance of understanding and adhering to state labor laws, ensuring that compensation practices are fair, transparent, and compliant with legal requirements. As New Jersey continues to strengthen protections for workers, this ruling stands as an important step in the ongoing effort to create a more equitable and just workplace for all.
Explore New Jersey—a state committed to fair labor practices and the protection of workers’ rights.