Hudson County is stepping into a new chapter in its law enforcement leadership. On July 31, 2025, Wayne Mello officially took the helm as Acting Prosecutor of the Hudson County Prosecutor’s Office (HCPO), a move announced by New Jersey Attorney General Matthew J. Platkin. Mello’s appointment follows the retirement of long-serving Prosecutor Esther Suarez, who held the post since 2015 and left behind a legacy of dedication to justice and community safety.
This leadership transition marks more than a change in title; it signifies a renewed focus on fighting violent crime, enhancing investigative capabilities, and maintaining a strong, consistent approach to justice throughout Hudson County.
For the latest on legal and public safety developments in New Jersey, visit our Law & Order section.
From First Assistant to Acting Prosecutor: Mello’s Proven Track Record
Wayne Mello is no stranger to Hudson County’s legal landscape. Since 2016, he has served as the HCPO’s First Assistant Prosecutor, working side-by-side with Suarez to oversee some of the most complex and high-profile cases in the county. With his promotion to Acting Prosecutor, Mello now steps into a leadership role where he will supervise an impressive team of 70 assistant prosecutors and over 100 detectives.
Under his direction, the HCPO will continue its aggressive pursuit of justice in areas such as violent crime, gun violence, narcotics trafficking, cybercrime, and organized gang activity. Mello’s extensive experience and hands-on approach are expected to provide seamless continuity in the office’s mission to uphold law and order across Hudson County.
Attorney General Platkin praised Mello’s qualifications, highlighting his “valuable prosecutorial and leadership experience, institutional knowledge, and heartfelt work on behalf of victims.” Mello’s meticulous attention to detail and deep respect among his peers—both prosecutors and defense attorneys—make him a natural fit for the top job at HCPO.
A Career Built on Pursuing Justice: Mello’s Most Notable Cases
Before rising through the ranks in Hudson County, Wayne Mello built a formidable reputation in Morris and Bergen County Prosecutor’s Offices, with a particular focus on homicide investigations. His courtroom tenacity and relentless pursuit of truth have been showcased in several cases that left lasting impacts on New Jersey’s legal history.
One of Mello’s most high-profile victories came in the 2006 Ramsey homicide case involving Edward Ates. Ates was charged with the calculated and cold-blooded murder of his former son-in-law, Paul Duncsak. In a case that captivated media attention, Ates’ defense claimed that his significant weight and related health issues made it physically impossible for him to commit the crime. However, Mello dismantled this narrative, presenting meticulous evidence that Ates had researched gun silencers, lock-picking, and how to commit murder. He also proved Ates conspired with his sister to create a false alibi. The result? A conviction for first-degree murder and a life sentence without parole eligibility for over 63 years.
Mello also brought justice in the tragic case of Jody Ann Scharf, whose death had remained unsolved for over a decade. Initially ruled undetermined, her death from a fall at Palisades Interstate Park was later reopened and rigorously investigated by Mello and his team. They uncovered that her injuries were inconsistent with an accidental fall and, in fact, pointed to homicide. Mello successfully secured a murder conviction against Scharf’s husband, Stephen F. Scharf, bringing closure to a case long thought to be unsolvable.
These cases exemplify Mello’s relentless dedication to ensuring that justice prevails—even when the odds seem stacked against it.
Military Service, Academic Excellence, and Community Commitment
Wayne Mello’s path to becoming Acting Prosecutor is grounded in a lifetime of service. A graduate of St. Peter’s University in Jersey City and Rutgers School of Law, Mello has deep educational roots in New Jersey. He was admitted to the New Jersey Bar in 1977, launching a legal career that has now spanned nearly five decades.
Beyond the courtroom, Mello served his country with honor during the Vietnam War, achieving the rank of Infantry First Lieutenant in the United States Army. His military experience instilled a disciplined approach to leadership, strategy, and integrity—qualities that have become the hallmarks of his prosecutorial style.
In accepting his new role, Mello expressed his gratitude and commitment: “I am profoundly grateful and honored to be asked by Attorney General Platkin to serve in this position. I look forward to taking on the challenges of the role and having the opportunity to stand up for victims, pursue justice, improve public safety, and ensure the well-being of all Hudson County residents.”
What’s Next for the Hudson County Prosecutor’s Office?
With Wayne Mello now leading the charge, Hudson County can expect a steadfast and experienced hand guiding its prosecutorial operations. His deep knowledge of the county’s legal framework, coupled with decades of field experience, positions the HCPO to tackle pressing issues such as gun violence, organized crime, drug distribution networks, and the ever-evolving landscape of cybercrime.
Under his leadership, the office aims to expand on the foundation built by Esther Suarez, who significantly enhanced the HCPO’s investigative capacities, emergency response readiness, and victim advocacy programs.
For the latest updates on law enforcement initiatives, major court cases, and public safety efforts in Hudson County, keep an eye on our dedicated Law & Order coverage.
Final Thoughts: Hudson County’s Justice System in Capable Hands
The appointment of Wayne Mello as Acting Hudson County Prosecutor brings a sense of assurance to residents and the broader New Jersey legal community. His track record speaks volumes—marked by a relentless pursuit of justice, deep respect for the legal process, and a commitment to serving victims and safeguarding communities.
As Hudson County faces the complex challenges of today’s criminal landscape, Mello’s leadership will ensure the fight for justice continues with focus, fairness, and unwavering dedication.
Stay informed with Explore New Jersey as we continue to bring you in-depth coverage of law enforcement leadership and public safety initiatives through our Law & Order news hub.
