New Brunswick’s George Street Playhouse is set to captivate theatergoers this fall with a production that promises intrigue, dark humor, and unforgettable performances. The theater has announced that Sally Struthers, two-time Emmy and Golden Globe Award winner and beloved for her role on All in the Family, will star as the formidable “Mrs. Peck” in An Old-Fashioned Family Murder. The play is penned by Tony Award winner Joe DiPietro, whose works, including Clever Little Lies, have consistently earned praise for their wit, emotional depth, and clever storytelling.
A Perfect Match: Struthers and DiPietro
Struthers’ casting as Mrs. Peck brings both star power and seasoned talent to the production. Known for her ability to balance comedy and drama with impeccable timing, she is poised to bring a new dimension to DiPietro’s sharp, character-driven narrative. DiPietro’s script delves into family secrets, twisted dynamics, and the surprises that lurk beneath the surface of seemingly ordinary lives—material that Struthers is uniquely equipped to bring to life.
The production is helmed by Larry Raben, celebrated for his work on Beautiful: The Carole King Musical, whose direction promises to balance the play’s suspenseful moments with its comedic undertones. Together, Struthers, DiPietro, and Raben form a creative team that promises an engaging and memorable experience for audiences.
Performance Schedule and Tickets
The show will begin previews on Tuesday, October 14, 2025, with an official opening night on Friday, October 17, 2025. The run continues through Sunday, November 2, 2025, providing a limited opportunity to experience this highly anticipated production. As always, George Street Playhouse shows are in high demand, so securing tickets early is recommended.
Why This Production Matters
George Street Playhouse has been a central pillar of New Jersey’s theater scene for decades, known for its commitment to professional productions that highlight both emerging and established talent. Each season brings audiences fresh stories, Broadway-level performances, and a dedication to artistic excellence. An Old-Fashioned Family Murder continues this tradition, offering both local theater enthusiasts and visitors from across the state a chance to experience compelling storytelling in an intimate, yet professional, setting.
For theater lovers, this production offers a rare combination: the magnetic presence of a celebrated television and stage star, a Tony Award-winning playwright’s sharp writing, and a director with Broadway experience ensuring every scene hits its mark. The result is an evening that promises laughter, suspense, and the kind of character-driven storytelling that keeps audiences talking long after the curtain falls.
Plan Your Visit
Located in the heart of New Brunswick, George Street Playhouse is easily accessible and offers a full calendar of performances that showcase the best of New Jersey’s theater talent. Whether you are a longtime theater enthusiast or exploring the arts scene for the first time, this fall’s production is a must-see event.
For more details on An Old-Fashioned Family Murder and other theater happenings across the state, visit Explore New Jersey Theatre. Stay updated on tickets, showtimes, and special events to make the most of your theater experience this fall.
