As New Jersey approaches a pivotal gubernatorial primary, a fresh wave of voter sentiment is starting to reshape the race. According to a new statewide poll, Democratic Congresswoman Mikie Sherrill and Republican Jack Ciattarelli are emerging as the clear frontrunners in their respective primaries. But this isn’t just about who’s leading — it’s about what issues matter most to New Jerseyans and how these candidates represent a shift in political energy across the Garden State.
This political moment offers a deeper look into the minds of voters, revealing sharp divides over the economy, immigration, public safety, and what kind of leadership the state needs moving forward. For more insight into these shifting dynamics, visit our Politics section.
Mikie Sherrill’s Surge Among Democratic Voters
Mikie Sherrill’s campaign has gained major traction, especially among voters over the age of 50 and those with a college degree. Now polling at 28%, she has nearly tripled her support from earlier this year. Her blend of military service, legislative experience, and moderate messaging appears to be striking the right chord with Democrats seeking pragmatic and future-focused leadership.
While fellow Democratic contenders like Mayors Steven Fulop and Ras Baraka, along with Reps. Josh Gottheimer and Sean Spiller, are all locked at 11%, a notable 24% of voters remain undecided. This leaves the door open for movement, but Sherrill’s growing base and name recognition give her a strong edge.
Jack Ciattarelli Still the GOP Favorite
On the Republican side, Jack Ciattarelli continues to lead the field with 44% of voter support, solidifying his role as the frontrunner for the party’s nomination. Having run in 2021, Ciattarelli has maintained his visibility and tapped into voter frustration around the economy, state taxes, and national political dynamics.
Trailing him are Bill Spadea with 18% and Jon Bramnick with 8%. However, with 23% of Republican voters still undecided, there’s room for surprises as the primary nears.
Voter Priorities: Economy, Housing, and Immigration Top the List
Economic stress is weighing heavily on New Jersey voters. Forty-five percent say the economy is their top issue, followed by 12% who cite housing affordability. These concerns cut across party lines and reflect deep worries about inflation, job security, and the soaring cost of living.
Other significant voter concerns include threats to democracy (11%) and immigration policy (9%). While Democrats are more likely to cite democracy and civil rights as priorities, Republicans and independents are gravitating toward border security and public safety.
Public Safety and Immigration Enforcement Spark Mixed Reactions
A plurality of New Jersey voters (46%) believe recent deportation efforts under the Trump administration have made their communities safer, while 24% say they feel less safe, and 31% say the efforts have had no effect. These stark divisions mirror national debates on immigration enforcement and law enforcement oversight.
The recent arrest of Newark Mayor Ras Baraka for protesting outside an immigration detention facility has also drawn mixed reactions. Forty-four percent support the arrest, while 38% oppose it, and 18% remain undecided or unaware. This episode has sparked deeper conversations around activism, civil liberties, and the role of local leaders in federal policy conflicts.
Leadership Style: Cooperation vs. Resistance
One of the most telling aspects of the poll centers around how voters want the next governor to approach the federal government. A narrow majority (53%) say they want the next governor to work with the Trump administration, while 47% prefer someone who will push back against it.
This divide is deeply partisan: 76% of Democrats want resistance, while 90% of Republicans favor collaboration. Interestingly, independents lean more Republican in this regard, with 60% wanting cooperation and 40% siding with Democrats.
These numbers indicate that swing voters — particularly moderates and independents — could tip the scales in a general election matchup, especially on hot-button issues like federal-state relations and civil liberties.
Newark Airport and the Crisis of Confidence
Another issue fueling voter concern is the air traffic control crisis at Newark Liberty International Airport. With over 80% of voters closely following this story, it’s become a flashpoint for debates around federal responsibility, safety, and infrastructure investment.
Voters are split on who to blame: 31% fault the Trump administration, 29% blame the FAA, 20% point to the Biden administration, and smaller percentages blame Governor Murphy and Congress. Alarmingly, 53% say they would feel unsafe taking a flight from Newark today.
This issue underscores the urgent need for comprehensive infrastructure reform and transparent leadership — a recurring theme in voters’ expectations for the next administration. Stay informed on how these developments impact technology, business, and daily life in New Jersey in our Politics section.
Looking Ahead: A State at a Crossroads
As the primaries approach, New Jersey’s political landscape remains fluid and fiercely competitive. While Mikie Sherrill and Jack Ciattarelli lead their respective fields, nothing is guaranteed. High levels of undecided voters, razor-thin divides on core issues, and the ever-present pressure of national politics mean that this year’s race will likely go down to the wire.
New Jersey voters aren’t just choosing a governor — they’re defining what kind of state they want to live in for the next decade. Economic leadership, public safety, and federal-state relations will all play critical roles in determining the winner.
Follow Explore New Jersey for exclusive political coverage, voter guides, and the stories shaping the future of the Garden State. For the latest updates and analysis, visit our Politics section.