When it comes to pizza in the Garden State, everyone’s got an opinion—and if you’re Dave Portnoy, those opinions come served hot, often with a side of sass. As the face behind Barstool Sports’ viral “One Bite” Pizza Reviews, Dave has made his way through some of New Jersey’s most talked-about pizzerias—and let’s just say, the slices weren’t the only things spicy.
On a whirlwind New Jersey pizza crawl, Dave stopped at a handful of local joints—each with its own flavor, following, and drama. Whether it was unsolicited advice from a customer or an avalanche of menu items being thrown his way, this pizza tour was anything but bland.
Curious where these spots land on the Jersey pizza map? Dive deeper into the state’s best pies and hidden gems on our NJ Pizza Guide here.
🍕 Vinnie’s Mootz – Lyndhurst, NJ: A Cheesy Send-Off
Dave wrapped up his New Jersey trip with a visit to Vinnie’s Mootz in Lyndhurst, a spot that had been tagging him relentlessly on social media. While some restaurants might quietly hope for a high score, Vinnie’s went all in to get noticed—and it paid off.
Located in Bergen County, Vinnie’s Mootz blends classic New Jersey thin crust with house-made mozzarella that gives the place its name (“mootz” being classic Jersey slang for mozzarella). The vibe is old-school-meets-modern, and their attention to crust crispiness didn’t go unnoticed.
Verdict: A solid slice with standout cheese. Tagging worked—but the pizza held its own.
🍕 Corner Square – Bayonne, NJ: Stuffed and Surprised
Next stop: Corner Square in Bayonne, where Dave was practically buried in food. While his reviews typically stick to one slice, Corner Square went full send, loading him up with what felt like the entire menu.
That could be a risk—too much food can distract from the main event—but Dave stayed focused on the slice. Bayonne locals are passionate about this place, and Corner Square clearly wanted to make a lasting impression. Their square slices hit a nostalgic note for fans of traditional grandma-style pies, with a crunchy bottom and balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio.
Verdict: More than just a pizza shop—Corner Square aimed for a full-on culinary experience. But the pizza still held center stage.
🍕 Oakwood Pizza – Edison, NJ: A Slice of Drama
At Oakwood Pizza in Edison, things took an unexpected turn right out of the gate. Before Dave could even take a bite, a local customer approached and told him he was at the “wrong location”—that the “real” pizza experience was tied to the old ownership.
Only in Jersey would a pizza review spark neighborhood loyalty debates in real-time.
Despite the awkward start, Dave gave the current Oakwood a fair shot. The slice was well-made, with a generous amount of cheese and a crust that tried hard to impress. But when the review is pre-loaded with controversy, it’s hard to separate the food from the fanfare.
Verdict: Solid slice, but the legacy and expectations loomed large. Pizza politics are real in New Jersey.
🍕 Ferraro’s Pizzeria & Pub – Middlesex, NJ: Familiar Flavors
Rounding out the tour, Dave visited Ferraro’s in Middlesex, a spot that claims to channel the kind of pies he typically favors—classic, clean, and no gimmicks.
Set up as both a pizzeria and pub, Ferraro’s leans into the community vibe, offering everything from slices to sit-down dinners. The pizza came out hot, with a thin, foldable crust and a tangy sauce that fans say separates Ferraro’s from the pack.
The review was free of theatrics, giving the pizza a chance to speak for itself—and that worked in its favor.
Verdict: A dependable, no-nonsense slice that hits the Jersey sweet spot. Nothing flashy, just solid execution.
🍕 Why New Jersey Pizza Deserves the Hype
If Dave Portnoy’s pizza tour did anything, it was remind us that New Jersey’s pizza scene is one of the most passionate and diverse in the country. Every town has its favorite spot, every resident has an opinion, and every slice comes with a story.
From corner shops to multi-generational family joints, pizza is more than just food here—it’s culture. And that’s why when someone like Dave shows up with a camera and a catchphrase, the stakes feel sky-high.
🍽️ Explore More New Jersey Pizza Gold
Whether you’re chasing viral spots from Barstool’s reviews or just hunting for your new go-to neighborhood slice, we’ve got you covered. Head over to our full New Jersey Pizza Guide for top-rated joints, local favorites, and everything in between.
From thin crust to grandma squares, and wood-fired to coal-oven, there’s a slice for every taste in the Garden State.
Because here in Jersey, we don’t just eat pizza—we live it.
Explore New Jersey is your guide to all things local—from the best pizza and burgers to must-see events, hidden gems, and family fun. Hungry for more? Stick with us for the latest reviews, recommendations, and road-trip-worthy eats across the state.