Second Street Bakery

A true neighborhood gem, Second Street Bakery has been serving up some of New Jersey’s favorite Italian comfort foods for decades. Known for its no-frills charm and unbeatable flavors, this old-school, cash-only bakery specializes in hearty Italian sandwiches piled high with fresh ingredients, savory stuffed breads that are perfect for sharing, and classic desserts baked with tradition in mind.

Step inside and you’ll find a menu that speaks to the heart of Italian-American cooking. Locals rave about the oversized sandwiches, packed with meats, cheeses, and all the right seasonings. The stuffed breads are legendary, baked to golden perfection and bursting with flavor in every bite. And if you’ve got a sweet tooth, the dessert case will keep you coming back for more.

What Makes Second Street Bakery Special?

• Authentic, old-world Italian recipes made fresh daily

• Hearty sandwiches and stuffed breads that have earned a loyal following

• Classic desserts crafted with the perfect mix of tradition and taste

• A true local favorite—cash-only for that authentic, no-nonsense vibe

Whether you’re grabbing lunch on the go, picking up something for the family, or simply craving the kind of food that feels like home, Second Street Bakery delivers timeless flavors with every order.