8 New Jersey Pizza Places Invited to Dave Portnoy’s One Bite Pizza Festival

Dave Portnoy, the influential pizza aficionado and founder of Barstool Sports, is gearing up for his second annual One Bite Pizza Festival, scheduled for September 14 at Randall’s Island Park in New York City. This festival, billed as an all-you-can-eat extravaganza, will feature 35 of Portnoy’s highest-rated pizza joints from around the United States, including a notable presence from New Jersey.

As anticipation builds for Dave Portnoy’s second annual One Bite Pizza Festival, scheduled for September 14th at Randall’s Island Park in New York City, pizza enthusiasts are eager to see which pizzerias will represent New Jersey at this prestigious event. Known for his passionate reviews and love of pizza, Portnoy has handpicked a stellar lineup of 35 of the highest-rated pizza parlors from across the country to participate in this all-you-can-eat extravaganza. Among them, New Jersey’s vibrant pizza scene is well represented, with eight standout establishments receiving coveted invitations.

1. Razza Pizza Artigianale – Located in Jersey City, Razza is celebrated for its artisanal approach to pizza making, focusing on locally sourced ingredients and a wood-fired oven that produces perfectly charred crusts.
2. De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies – With locations in Robbinsville and Trenton, De Lorenzo’s is renowned for its thin-crust tomato pies, a New Jersey specialty that emphasizes fresh tomato sauce and minimal toppings.
3. Santillo’s Brick Oven Pizza – Hailing from Elizabeth, Santillo’s is famous for its historical significance and dedication to preserving traditional pizza-making techniques in a brick oven that dates back over a century.
4. Pete & Elda’s Bar / Carmen’s Pizzeria – Located in Neptune City, Pete & Elda’s is synonymous with massive, thin-crust “XXL” pizzas and a lively atmosphere that has made it a Jersey Shore institution.
5. Arturo’s Osteria & Pizzeria – Situated in Maplewood, Arturo’s is beloved for its rustic Italian fare and Neapolitan-style pizzas, which showcase high-quality ingredients and expert craftsmanship.
6. Star Tavern Pizzeria – A staple of Orange, Star Tavern is famous for its thin-crust, bar-style pizza topped generously with cheese and served in a welcoming, family-friendly setting.
7. Benny Tudino’s – Located in Hoboken, Benny Tudino’s is renowned for its enormous, foldable slices and has become a favorite among locals and visitors alike for its no-frills approach to classic pizza.
8. Porta – With locations in Jersey City and Asbury Park, Porta offers a lively dining experience centered around wood-fired pizzas crafted with fresh, seasonal ingredients and a focus on communal dining.

Each of these New Jersey pizzerias brings a unique flavor and tradition to the table, representing the state’s rich pizza heritage and culinary diversity. Their participation in Dave Portnoy’s One Bite Pizza Festival not only highlights their excellence but also provides attendees with an opportunity to savor some of the Garden State’s finest pizza creations.

As September 14th approaches, pizza lovers and festival-goers alike are eagerly awaiting the chance to sample slices from these and other top-rated pizzerias, all set against the backdrop of Randall’s Island Park and Dave Portnoy’s enthusiastic celebration of pizza culture. It promises to be an unforgettable day of indulgence, community, and, of course, plenty of delicious pizza.

In a testament to New Jersey’s thriving pizza scene, eight local establishments have made the cut for Portnoy’s festival lineup. Each of these joints has earned impressive scores from Portnoy himself, highlighting the state’s dedication to producing top-tier pizza:

1. Angeloni’s Restaurant & Pizzeria, Caldwell – 8.8
2. Brooklyn Square Pizza, Jackson, Toms River, and Manalapan – 8.9
3. Bunny’s Sports Bar, South Orange – 8.3
4. Calabria Pizzeria & Restaurant, Livingston – 8.9
5. De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pie, Robbinsville Township – 9.2
6. Federici’s Family Restaurant, Freehold Borough – 8.8
7. Lillo’s Tomato Pies, Hainesport – 8.4
8. Santillo’s Brick Oven Pizza, Elizabeth – 8.3

These scores reflect the rigorous standards of Portnoy’s One Bite reviews, where each pizza is evaluated on a scale from 1 to 10 based on its crust, sauce, cheese, and overall taste. For a state to claim nearly a quarter of the festival’s slots is no small feat, underscoring New Jersey’s reputation as a pizza haven within the culinary world.

Portnoy’s reviews are known not only for their critical acclaim but also for their impact on local businesses. A positive review from Portnoy can catapult a pizzeria to national fame, while a less-than-stellar rating can prompt improvements or changes in recipe.

As pizza enthusiasts and foodies eagerly anticipate the festival, it’s clear that New Jersey’s pizza makers are ready to showcase their best slices alongside other top contenders from across the country. For those attending, it promises to be a celebration of pizza artistry and culinary excellence, guided by the discerning palate of Dave Portnoy himself.

Dave Portnoy’s Second Annual One Bite Pizza Festival: A Slice of Pizza Paradise, as Pizza lovers rejoice! Dave Portnoy, the founder of Barstool Sports and renowned pizza aficionado, is gearing up for the second annual One Bite Pizza Festival, set to take place on September 14th at Randall’s Island Park in New York City. This eagerly anticipated event promises to be a celebration of all things pizza, featuring a mouthwatering lineup of 35 of Portnoy’s highest-rated pizza parlors from across the United States.

What makes this festival unique is its dedication to showcasing the best of the best in the pizza world. Portnoy, famous for his “One Bite” pizza reviews where he takes a single bite and delivers his verdict, has become a trusted authority on what constitutes a great slice. Attendees at the festival will have the opportunity to indulge in an all-you-can-eat pizza extravaganza, sampling slices from some of the most esteemed pizzerias handpicked by Portnoy himself.

Randall’s Island Park, with its scenic views of the East River and Manhattan skyline, provides the perfect backdrop for this culinary event. As pizza enthusiasts gather under the late summer sun, they can expect a vibrant atmosphere filled with the aroma of freshly baked dough, bubbling cheese, and an array of savory toppings.

The festival not only celebrates the artistry of pizza making but also serves as a platform for pizza makers to showcase their craft and connect with a passionate community of food lovers. From traditional New York-style slices to Neapolitan pies and innovative gourmet creations, the diversity of offerings ensures there’s something to please every palate.

For Portnoy, whose love for pizza is infectious and widely known through his viral reviews and social media presence, the One Bite Pizza Festival is a chance to share his passion with fans and fellow pizza enthusiasts alike. It’s a testament to the cultural significance of pizza in American cuisine and a nod to the hardworking pizzeria owners and chefs who dedicate themselves to perfecting this beloved dish.

Tickets to the festival are highly coveted, with anticipation building as the date approaches. Attendees can expect not only a gastronomic adventure but also entertainment, music, and perhaps even surprise appearances by celebrity guests and fellow Barstool personalities.

As September 14th draws near, pizza lovers from near and far are marking their calendars and preparing their appetites for what promises to be an unforgettable day at Dave Portnoy’s One Bite Pizza Festival. Whether you’re a seasoned pizza connoisseur or simply someone who appreciates a good slice, this event is sure to deliver a slice of pizza paradise right in the heart of New York City.

You can watch every Dave Portnoy Pizza Joint Review from New Jersey right here at ENJ!